Hello dear
Welcome to Pizza Shack I
Welcome to Pizza Shack I, nestled in Spencerport, NY. Known for its exceptional pizza and crispy wings, this eatery has quickly become a local favorite. Customers rave about the rich sauce and perfect crust, with many claiming it’s the best pizza they’ve tasted in Rochester. The menu features a variety of munchies, including onion rings and cheddar jalapeno poppers, adding to the satisfying experience. If you're craving flavorful, hearty pizza, Pizza Shack I is your new go-to spot. Their commitment to quality is evident, and with glowing reviews from delighted diners, this hidden gem deserves a visit!
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Onion Rings
French Fries
Mozzarella Sticks
Pizza Logs
About
Pizza Shack I
Welcome to Pizza Shack I, a culinary gem nestled in Spencerport, NY, where the aroma of delicious pizza wafts through the air, hinting at the tasty experience that awaits you. Located at 5008 W Ridge Rd, this establishment prides itself on serving up some of the finest pizza in the Rochester area, drawing in locals and newcomers alike.
When you step into Pizza Shack I, you’ll immediately feel the warmth of a welcoming atmosphere. The menu is a testament to their dedication to quality and flavor. Customers rave about their thick crust pizza, often hailed as one of the best around Rochester. One patron, Reed Brodsky, highlighted the superb quality, mentioning that it's among the best he's tasted. The pizza is cooked to perfection, boasting a delectable sauce that enhances every bite. This sentiment is echoed by various customers who describe their experiences with a mouthwatering enthusiasm.
But Pizza Shack I is not merely about pizza. The extensive lineup of munchies elevates the dining experience. From crispy onion rings and mozzarella sticks to savory cheddar jalapeno poppers, the appetizers here are designed to tantalize your taste buds and complement your main course beautifully. Don’t forget to try their deep-fried mushrooms or clam strips for a delightful crunch that pairs perfectly with their pizza offerings.
The stellar reviews speak wonders about their wings, with one customer praising their perfectly fried texture, achieving the right balance of crispy without being overly tough. It’s no surprise that many consider this eatery a hidden treasure, with Holly Williams boldly stating it’s the best pizza in Rochester!
For those in a hurry, it's wise to call ahead as the pizza takes around 25 minutes to prepare; however, it is guaranteed to be worth the wait. The staff, dedicated even during busy hours, ensure that orders are delivered promptly, maintaining high standards for food quality and service.
All in all, Pizza Shack I is not just another pizzeria; it’s a communal spot where flavor and comfort unite. Whether you are with family or friends, this place promises a pizza experience that could very well become your favorite. With glowing testimonials from customers like Sam Donato and Takierra E., it’s clear that once you’ve tasted a slice from Pizza Shack I, you’ll be coming back for more.
To explore this deliciousness yourself, be sure to contact them at +1 585-352-5005 and make your way to 5008 W Ridge Rd. Your taste buds will thank you!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ New to the area so I’ve been trying the local pizza places nearby. This was my 3rd new place that my family and I have tried out and we have found our new pizza home. The food was delicious pizza was delicious sauce was awesome. The wings were the best that I’ve had in this area to date. Asked to fry hard and they were fried just right and not too tough. We will definitely be returning. ”
“ If you’re planning on eating here, pizza takes about 25 min to make so order ahead. If you’re in the area this might be the best thick crust pizza I’ve had around Rochester. Found this place randomly and had high higher reviews than other joints in the area, I’m not surprised why. Simply good pizza. ”
“ Pizza shack on ridge is where you’ll find the best pizza in the nation. ”
“ Absolutely delicious! Hands down best pizza in Rochester! Hidden gem! ”
“ Wow, I have been on the hunt for a great pizza in ROC. This one is top 2 for me locally. Everything about this pizza is just the way I like it. Ordered a large cheese, pepperoni, mushroom, thin crust, pink sauce well done. They were slammed busy at the time, but I got my order in the time they promised still. ”
“ Staff are great, been ordering from them for years. They remember you and how you order. There's no where better!! ”
“ Got a large, thin crust, pepperoni cooked well done. Came out nice and crisp, not burnt. Sauce is perfectly seasoned and delicious; did not have to add anything. Price was great, cash only business. My family rated Pizza Shack a 10! We found our new pizza spot! ”
“ I've always enjoyed the food here but have recently become a regular. Consistently good food (pizza & wings being my favorite of course), very friendly staff (it was my pleasure to make the current owner's acquaintance), & decent hours (I tend to dine late on take-out). A nice, small, family owned pizza place, which is where you get the best pizza as a rule. Keep up the good work guys! ”